Carlo Piana :: Law is Freedom ::
... and Freedom is all the rest
Home ›

Creative Commons

A modest proposal to give Free Software equal legal standing as proprietary.

Submitted by Carlo on Tue, 01/03/2012 - 13:13
  • News
  • Civil Law
  • Free software, digital liberties
  • Creative Commons
  • Free Software
  • Interoperability
  • Normation

Note: Updated to include lock-in and tying. Some changes on moral rights to clarify that

Laws are more often than not an annoyance, despite their aim to improve the legal framework in any given field. Free Software (AKA "Open Source") has thrived despite the absence of any legal recognition by the law, if not in spite of rules that clearly are shaped around proprietary software. In many jurisdictions it has passed the enforceability test. So, no laws seem necessary to make it work. Yet, can some legal principle be put forward, and included in some laws, to help?

"If it works don't fix it", so goes the common saying. But if it works now doesn't mean it will work forever. It is nevertheless upon lawyers, and legislators alike, to foresee problems ahead of their actual happening, and brace for the potential harmful event. But any laws that would regulate Free Software would likely harm some parts of it, and change the games to favor one kind over another, or impose conditions that are not welcome or productive – something that legislator, even with the best intentions, often do – and in general could cause as many troubles as they would produce benefit. "Primum non nocere" is the paradigm for medical actions, even though drugs by definition only produce a net benefit by inflicting some limited damage. Is there a medicament that has entirely good effects without any negative ones? Arguably there is not. But with laws we can achieve something closer to this optimal benefit, which economists know as "Pareto Efficiency".

So this is a call for Pareto Efficient Laws, and Pareto optimal only laws.

  • Read more

New Free Software Law Review

Submitted by Carlo on Tue, 07/14/2009 - 09:55
  • News
  • From other sources
  • Free software, digital liberties
  • Creative Commons

Front PagePatron the Freedom Task Force of the FSFE, yesterday a new review, the International Free and Open Source Law Review, or IFOSS L. Rev, has been announced and published.

It is a "peer reviewed" publication, whose aim is to offer a sound and detached vision of the legal and social phenomenon of Free Software. It hosts voices from people with legal, economical and on-the-field background. The review is governed in a non partisan way by an editorial committee of fifteen members that partly rotate at each issue. I have been in the panel for the first issue, and possibly will serve as a member for the second one.

Any contribution is welcome and will be passed through an impartial evaluation by the international standard and practices.

  • Read more
  • Italian

JC De Martin

  • amici
  • Creative Commons

JC De Martin

http://demartin.polito.it
  • Carlo's links

Arcoiris

  • Media
  • Creative Commons
  • Interoperabilità

Arcoiris

http://www.arcoiris.tv

Arcoiris TV

  • Carlo's links
Syndicate content

Main menu

  • Law Practice
  • Articles
  • News
  • mu-blog
  • Info

Languages

  • English
  • Italian
© Carlo Piana [creative commons by-sa 3.0 if not otherwise stated]